This is a big one, in every sense of the word. With the original Avengers cast, the Guardians of the Galaxy cast as well as various other Marvel superheroes who have graced the silver screen such as Black Panther and Doctor Strange, it’s pretty clear that this is a landmark movie for the studio. I’ll break this down into three parts: firstly, how I think the plot will flow in general, next, some specific plot points I think we’ll see and finally, how I think the overall quality of the film will be.
1. General Plot Flow
While an increase in the number of famous and familiar faces seems concomitant with the level of hype, at this level, I think it’s inevitable that some degree of diminishing returns will set in. Because it just seems way too crowded. I think there’s three ways the film can go:
1. It’ll try to capture every hero as much as possible, but maintaining a clear focus on a few key characters, such as Iron Man and Captain America. This would more or less be the way that Civil War went, which was directed by the Russo brothers (who direct this movie), where every character gets their part to play alongside Capt and Iron Man, culminating in the airport fight scene. This time though, it’ll be a bit more of a squeeze as characters like Spiderman, Black Panther and the Guardians all look to have significant parts to play. I can see each group or individual having their own unique part to play; perhaps to defeat a certain henchman of Thanos (of which there are 4, who haven’t really shown up much in promotion material)
2. Thanos is the main character, the superheroes all play supporting roles to varying levels of importance. Producer Kevin Feige has mentioned that ‘you could almost go so far as to say he is the main character of the film.” I wonder if he means this in the vein of Ultron in Avengers: Age of Ultron, whoe perspective is shown constantly throughout the film or perhaps in a more insidious capacity such as ‘It’ in the titular It, where his presence is a constant overhang over everyone. I think it’d certainly be an interesting, and unprecedented move to instead make Thanos the actual main character; focusing on primarily on his perspective throughout the film. This could work as we’d follow him as he collects the Stones, which are all linked in different ways to the different characters in the film. Yet based on the trailers that have come out, which show the perspectives of many different characters such as Peter Parker and T’Challa, I don’t think we’re going to have a case where Thanos is the one voice and perspective. I think the most likely scenario would be mirroring that of Ultron, though with Thanos having greater weight comparatively, and the superhero cast playing more of a supporting role each.
3. Everyone’s screen time is shared somewhat equally. This scenario is the most problematic and the least plausible, because there’s just too many characters and too little time to reasonably allow everyone to have their own arc (I’m not talking about having a one-minute scene to themselves).
I think the most likely scenario to happen is actually the second, though the superheroes won’t exactly play ‘supporting’ roles, but instead a few of them will be co-leadish with Thanos.
Here’s something to consider:
Above is the screen time of the various characters in Captain America: Civil War (credit: vulture.com)
Civil War was more or less Avengers 2.5, with even more Avengers appearing than in the second one. I think what’s most interesting to note here is how the screen times of Captain America and Iron Man have been diffused with others to give everyone their own part of the story. I think it’s notable how everyone from Black Widow to Vision get about the same screen time, at around 10 minutes. Each had their own part; T’challa had the T’chaka’s death arc, Scarlet Witch deals with the guilt of starting the whole conflict in the first place, and so on. Because this was directed by the Russo brothers, I think we’d likely see a fair share of supporting characters with significant parts to play as well. In Civil War, Zemo, the main villain has 9 minutes of screen time, which I think is definitely not going to be the case with Thanos. I think we can expect 2-3 characters to have significantly more screen time, while several others have a fair amount. It’s worth noting though, that in the 2nd Avengers, Captain America and Iron Man had roughly 50 minutes and 45 minutes of screen time respectively, as compared to this case, where there are more characters in play. Thus I think a further diffusion of screen time from the leads may be possible; apart from Thanos, the ‘co-leads’ could each have 20-30 minutes of screen time to themselves.
Which heroes are these ‘co-leads’? This brings me to part 2.
2. Specific plot points
Well, I think the best place to start would be to continue from Part 1: I’m going to predict the characters that will have their perspectives shown to a large extent.
Of course, Thanos is a given, I think he’s probably going to have the largest share.
Captain America and Iron Man: These two have had the most screen time out of any other character so far in the MCU, and I don’t see that changing here, especially when Captain America is heavily expected to die in either this film or the next. They’ll want to give him a proper sendoff. Iron Man, on the other hand, I think we’ll see return to his roots (in Iron Man 1,2,3), where Pepper is the main focus of his life. I think he’s likely to get a build-up towards a sendoff as well, though whether he dies or just retires is anyone’s guess.
T’challa: He may feature heavily not just because Wakanda seems to be one of the prime battlefields in this film, but also because Black Panther was the most recent MCU movie and opened to enormous success. Studio heads may thus want him and the other Black Panther cast members to feature more because of the easy continuity with Black Panther likely still fresh in everyone’s mind, and I suspect may have added more of them in the editing stage just based on the incredible success of the movie.
Gamora (and maybe by extension, Nebula): Gamora (and Nebula) have the closest link there is to Thanos; they are his children. Since the trailers have revealed a flashback scene where Thanos first takes Gamora as his child, and since this does seem like a ‘origin’ story for Thanos and thus will likely pay notable focus to his past life, I think Gamora could feature very heavily in terms of her life with Thanos, and thus may prove significant in his undoing. (also, Nebula)
I think Thor and Black Widow are likely to have significant screen time as well, though their perspectives may not come into play as much (such as in the Age of Ultron). Doctor Strange and Spiderman probably have their fair share of time as well, though perhaps more so in the form action sequences rather than exposition.
Here’s something interesting to note:
Above is the screen time of the characters in Avengers: Age of Ultron. (credit: vulture.com)
It’s clear how certain characters have their screen times sacrificed for others; you can only fit so much in two and a half hours or so. Clearly, the one who lost out here was Thor, which is interesting to note because in the original Avengers, Thor got roughly 25 minutes of screen time, while Hawkeye got only 12 minutes of screen time. As you can see above, there was a definite reversal in this case. What prompted this? Two main factors: 1. Vocal fan complaints of the lack of Hawkeye in the first film. 2. The underwhelming 2nd Thor film preceding Age of Ultron.
While things may have changed since the Joss Whedon era, this shows the potentially very high impact that fan response has on these movies. This gives me reason to believe that T’challa and Thor will feature heavily (given the overwhelmingly positive response to the two recent MCU movies), which is why they’re included above. Fans have been clamouring for a Black Widow solo movie for a very long time, and when news came out that she wouldn’t get one, fans were unhappy to say the least. This film may thus give her a prominent role to make up for that.
Who stands to lose then? Probably Hawkeye and Ant-Man to the largest degree, whose no-show in all the promotional material so far has been noticed by many. Hawkeye is supposed to have his own ‘special journey’ in the film, but I feel that could be code for being written to be mostly uninvolved and have little screen time. I think this journey could be his transformation to Ronin, which would make sense as they’d have reason not to spoil his new look.
Death is pretty inevitable in such a large war movie, so here are the ones I think are most likely to die:
- Captain America: This one we kind of all know/have read about, though it could happen in the next movie
- Okoye: In the final (money) shot of the main trailer depicting the Avengers charging towards us, we see Ayo instead of Okoye with the group. This gives me reason to believe Okoye may be perished and passed the baton to Ayo.
- Vision: He may not fully die, but may be completely changed once Thanos retrieves the Stone from him.
- Black Widow: With no Black Widow film in the works, and with many of the main cast of the original Avengers set to take their bow, I think she may not survive either this movie or the next.
Other things that will probably happen:
Captain Marvel shows up in a post-credit scene.
Starlord appears only briefly, for some reason I can’t think of. Probably something to do with the purple Stone. (hence his inclusion on the poster with the qualifier “AND Chris Pratt”.
The Avengers separately battling Thanos’s henchmen will make up some of the key action sequences.
Okay, I think that’s it! Stay tuned for Part 2 which will cover my thoughts on what the quality of the film will be like.